Monday, 28 October 2013

NSA surveillance: Spain demands US explain 'monitoring' - BBC News

Demands are growing in Europe for explanations over US monitoring activities

Spain has urged the US to give details of any eavesdropping, amid reports it monitored 60 million Spanish telephone calls in a month.

The US ambassador to Spain, who had been summoned by its EU minister, vowed to clear the "doubts" that had arisen about his country's alleged espionage.

The minister, Inigo Mendez de Vigo, said such practices, if true, were "inappropriate and unacceptable".

An EU delegate in Washington said there had been "a breakdown of trust".

Representatives from the European Parliament's Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs spoke to members of the US Congress about the alleged US spying on European leaders and citizens.

"We wanted to transmit to them first that this mass surveillance of EU citizens is a genuine concern," British Labour MEP Claude Moraes, a member of the delegation, told the BBC after the meetings.

Labour MEP Claude Moraes: "They're giving us answers, but not the answers we want"

"I think they're listening to that. They want to have some sort of dialogue."

Spanish press review

Editorial in El Mundo: "The massive spying on Spanish citizens requires a strong response from the authorities... The foreign ministry should raise a formal complaint. Mariano Rajoy should join France and Germany in their initiatives. And as early as [Monday], the public prosecutor should denounce the NSA 'for violation of the privacy of millions of Spaniards, which is punishable by up to four years in prison under Article 197 of the Penal Code'."

Editorial in La Vanguardia: "The erosion of transatlantic confidence is evident and there may be significant consequences for the future of democracy unless a solution is found more or less immediately... In the coming days, a European delegation will visit President Obama to ask him about the background to the espionage. That should be the time to rebuild lost trust in each other."

Editorial in ABC: "Obama is not the first president to spy on leaders of other countries, including allies. What makes Obama different is that he is facing a terrorist threat of colossal dimensions, he is taking advantage of new technologies and he is a victim of the fragility of a world in which information flows unchecked and within seconds all secrets are revealed."

But Mr Moraes said he and his fellow delegates were unsatisfied with the "stock" responses from US officials on the issue.

"They're giving us answers, but not the answers we want," he said. "We're getting a bit tired of this, 'Well, spying has always existed.'"

German Chancellor Angela Merkel is also sending intelligence officials to Washington to demand answers to claims that her phones were tapped for a decade.

German media reported that the US had bugged Ms Merkel's phone for more than a decade - and that the surveillance only ended a few months ago.

The German government hoped that trust between the two countries could be restored, a spokesman told a news conference in Berlin.

"It would be disturbing if these suspicions turned out to be true. But Germany and the United States can solve this problem together," Steffen Seibert said.

"We will vigorously push ahead with the clarification of this case especially because we have a great interest in a good German-American relationships."

Meanwhile, a Japanese news agency says the US National Security Agency (NSA) asked the Japanese government in 2011 to help it monitor fibre-optic cables carrying personal data through Japan, to the Asia-Pacific region.

The reports, carried by Kyodo, say that this was intended to allow the US to spy on China, but that Japanese officials refused, citing legal restrictions and a shortage of personnel.

Contents 'not recorded'

The latest allegation, published by Spain's El Mundo newspaper, is that the NSA tracked tens of millions of phone calls, texts and emails of Spanish citizens, in December 2012 and January 2013. The monitoring allegedly peaked on 11 December.

The White House has so far declined to comment on the El Mundo report.

It is not clear how the alleged surveillance was carried out, whether it was through monitoring fibre-optic cables, data obtained from telecommunication companies, or other means.

The NSA is reported to have collected the sender and recipient addresses of emails, along with their IP addresses, the message file size, and sometimes the top or subject line of the message.

For each telephone call, the numbers of the caller and recipient are believed to have been logged, as was its duration, time, date and location.

The contents of the telephone call itself, however, were not monitored, US intelligence officials say. The NSA has also suggested it does not usually store the geolocational information of mobile phone calls, which could determined by noting which mobile signal towers were used.

Four die as storm hits southern UK - BBC News

Footage from across the south shows how the storm took hold, as Jeremy Cooke reports

Four people have died after a storm battered southern Britain, leading to 600,000 homes losing power, and rail and flight cancellations.

A teenager in Kent and a man in Watford were killed by falling trees.

A man and a woman died in west London after a falling tree caused a suspected gas explosion and house collapse.

Train companies are running reduced services but say they hope to run full services on Tuesday.

BBC forecasters say the storm, which saw heavy rain fall across many areas and wind speeds of more than 70mph, left the UK shortly after 12:00 GMT - leaving a "broadly windy day".

The strongest gust of 99mph (159km/h) was recorded at Needles Old Battery, Isle of Wight, at 05:00 GMT.

Travel warnings include:

  • South West Trains is running a severely reduced service
  • There is a limited number of East Coast trains running south of Peterborough
  • Virgin West Coast is starting to run limited services out of Euston
  • First Capital Connect has started to resume services but says the London to Luton will be closed all day
  • C2C said Some train services have resumed but major disruption remains
  • A reduced service is running on Greater Anglia but Stansted Express services remain suspended.
  • Southern and Gatwick Express said the Brighton mainline has now been cleared of trees and services are running on temporary timetable
  • Southeastern is operating a limited service on all routes, except for the Deal and Dover, Bat and Ball and Sevenoaks, Eynsford and Shoreham, and Otford and Maidstone East lines
  • First Great Western is running services on most routes, but with delays and alterations
  • Chiltern Railways is running a normal service but says there may be some delays and short notice cancellations
  • London Overground says there is no service between Camden Road and Richmond/Clapham Junction
  • Transport for London said the Piccadilly line west of Acton Town is the only Tube service now running with severe delays due to earlier debris on the tracks
  • Airports including Heathrow and Gatwick saw flight cancellations in the morning and are advising passengers to check with their airlines
  • The Port of Dover was shut at about 07:15 GMT but reopened at 09:10 and P&O said there may be delays to services
  • The Severn crossings re-opened, but flooding is still affecting roads in Wales
  • The Highways Agency is advising motorists to check the weather forecast and road conditions before they travel

Bethany Freeman, 17, suffered fatal injuries when the tree came down on the caravan where she was sleeping in Hever, near Edenbridge, at about 07:20 GMT.

The caravan was next to the house she lived in with her family and she had been sleeping there while renovations were carried out.

Donal Drohan, 51, from Harrow, was pronounced dead at the scene after a tree crushed a red Peugeot 307 at Lower High Street in Watford, Hertfordshire, at 6:50 GMT.

Mark Joseph, who was passing by before the emergency services arrived, said: "We tried to assist, trying to get the tree off, but it was impossible... The poor chap didn't stand a chance."

The man and women who died in west London were found after three houses collapsed and two others were damaged following a gas explosion after a tree fell during high winds in Hounslow, the London Fire Brigade said. Three people injured in the incident were taken to hospital.

Power restored

The Energy Networks Association, which represents power companies across the UK, confirmed 166,000 homes were still without power by 17:00 GMT.

A spokesman said 407,000 households which lost power earlier had been reconnected, but more had been cut off as the storm moved north and eastwards.

Network Rail said the damage to railway lines had been "worse than expected", with more than 100 trees on the lines.

Several hundred staff have been working to monitor conditions and react to damage.

Anthony Smith, chief executive of rail customer watchdog Passenger Focus, said it was "too early to tell if the industry made the right call when cancelling so many services, but the fact that major incidents have been avoided is good news".

The Environment Agency had dozens of flood warnings in place - in areas of south-west England, East Anglia and the Midlands where flooding was expected, but the number is now down to four. There are also more than 100 flood alerts, where flooding is possible, across England and Wales.

It says there is an increased risk of flooding from rivers following the heavy rainfall, and large waves and strong winds may continue to cause some minor coastal flooding along the south coast.

Prime Minister David Cameron said the deaths caused by the storm were "hugely regrettable".

Asked whether train companies had over-reacted, he said: "These are difficult things to handle because you don't know for certain just how strong the storm will be."

In other developments:

  • The search for the 14-year-old boy - who has been named as Dylan Alkins - who was swept away in Newhaven, East Sussex on Sunday has resumed
  • A double-decker bus "rolled over" in Suffolk, injuring the driver and several passengers. Witnesses told police the vehicle blew over at 08:00 GMT, rolling onto its side and coming to a stop in a field in Hadleigh
  • Both reactors in Dungeness power station's B units have been automatically shut down after power to the site was cut off. The site's own generators are providing power to the site
  • The Metropolitan Police says it received 792 calls to its 101 and 999 numbers between 06:00 and 08:00 GMT, compared with the 200 it would normally expect. The most common call was for "tree in road"
  • Sussex Police say 125 trees have fallen across Sussex - including one on a taxi in Eastbourne, from which the driver climbed out uninjured
  • The helter-skelter at Clacton Pier in Essex has blown down, but the structure has not fallen into the sea
  • London Mayor Boris Johnson has chaired an emergency resilience meeting involving all emergency services and relevant agencies - and later made a statement thanking them for their hard work "dealing with one of the fiercest storms of the last few years"
  • Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg has cancelled his monthly press conference because of a crane collapsed on the roof of the Cabinet Office

BBC weather forecasters said in more populous areas including Lyneham, near Swindon; Yeovilton in Somerset and Hurn, near Bournemouth, speeds of 74-75mph (119-121km/h) had been recorded.

It has released figures showing the strongest winds and heaviest rainfall during the storm - with Otterbourne in Hampshire receiving 50mm of rain.

Wind speeds of 115 mph were recorded during the so-called Great Storm of October 1987.

There is more information about the forecasts for Monday on the BBC Weather, Met Office and Environment Agency websites. See BBC Travel News for up to date travel information and the Highways Agency and Traffic Wales websites for details about road conditions. BBC Local has information from your area.

Have you been affected by the storm? Has the weather altered your plans or disrupted your travel? Please send us your comments using the form below.

Send your pictures and videos to yourpics@bbc.co.uk or text them to 61124 (UK) or +44 7624 800 100 (International). If you have a large file you can upload here.

Read the terms and conditions

NSA 'monitored 60m Spanish calls in a month' - BBC News

The US National Security Agency secretly monitored 60 million phone calls in Spain in one month, Spanish media say.

The reports say the latest allegations came from documents provided by the fugitive US analyst Edward Snowden.

They say the NSA collected the numbers and locations of the caller and the recipient, but not the calls' content.

This comes as a European Union parliamentary delegation prepares for a series of meetings in Washington.

The officials from the European parliament's Civil Liberties Committee will speak to members of Congress to convey concerns and gather information.

Citizens

Meanwhile a Japanese news agency says that the NSA asked the Japanese government in 2011 to help it monitor fibre-optic cables carrying personal data through Japan, to the Asia-Pacific region.

The reports, carried by the Kyodo news agency, say that this was intended to allow the US to spy on China - but Japan refused, citing legal restrictions and a shortage of personnel.

The White House has so far declined to comment on Monday's claims about US spying in Spain, published in the newspapers El Pais and El Mundo.

It is alleged that the NSA tracked millions of phone calls, texts and emails from Spanish citizens between 10 December 2012 and 8 January this year.

"Start Quote

It's about scale and proportionality"

End Quote Claude Moraes Head of the EU delegation

The US ambassador to Madrid has been summoned to meet a Spanish foreign ministry official later on Monday to discuss earlier allegations about US spying on Spanish citizens and politicians.

It follows German media reports that the US was bugging Chancellor Angela Merkel's phone for more than a decade - and that the surveillance only ended a few months ago.

Mrs Merkel is sending her country's top intelligence chiefs to Washington this week to "push forward" an investigation into the spying allegations, which have caused outrage in Germany.

Mass surveillance

Britain's Guardian newspaper reported on Friday that the NSA had monitored the phones of 35 world leaders. Again Mr Snowden was the source of the report.

The head of the European parliament delegation, British MEP Claude Moraes, told the BBC it was the scale of the NSA's alleged surveillance that was worrying.

"The headline news, that 35 leaders had their phones tapped is not the real crux of the issue," he said.

"It really is the El Mundo type story, that millions of citizens of countries... had their landlines and other communications tapped. So it's about mass surveillance. It's about scale and proportionality."

He said a priority of the European mission was to discuss the impact of American spying on EU citizens' fundamental right to privacy.

The BBC's Europe correspondent Chris Morris says that with every new allegation, demands are growing in Europe - and in Germany in particular - for explanations and for guarantees of a change in culture.

EU leaders have said that distrust of the US over spying could harm the fight against terrorism.

Advice on badger cull extension challenged - BBC News

England's chief vet has rejected accusations his advice to ministers on the badger cull risked bringing the veterinary profession into disrepute.

In official advice, Nigel Gibbons said extending the culling period would help to achieve the earliest and greatest possible impact on bovine TB.

But vets have questioned the grounds for the extension, saying it risked spreading TB to badgers and cattle.

Mr Gibbons said his advice was well founded and he would not retract it.

On Wednesday, Natural England granted a controversial eight-week extension to the badger cull in Gloucestershire, more than a week after a three-week extension in Somerset.

It followed the failure in both areas to shoot the planned target of 70% of the badger population over six weeks.

"Start Quote

The clear advice of the chief veterinary officer is that the more badgers removed in the first year of the cull, the greater and quicker reductions in cull area will be"

End Quote

Central to granting an extension to the cull was advice from the chief vet, Nigel Gibbons.

In his official guidance, Nigel Gibbons said: "If the number of badgers culled is short of the target reduction, leaving a high badger population in the area, the benefit of reducing the disease risk to cattle from that badger population by extending the period of culling to reduce the badger population is likely to outweigh the perturbation impact of leaving a high badger population."

However, 10 members of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons questioned this advice in a letter seen by the BBC.

They wrote: "We are concerned that the advice you are giving in relation to the results of the pilot badger culls and their extension could result in increased suffering of badgers, and place both badgers and cattle in and around the cull zones at greater risk of contracting bovine tuberculosis.

"The advice is also being issued before the independent expert panel, convened to examine the results of the pilot culls, has had any opportunity to study those results and deliver its opinion."

Devastating disease

Mark Jones, one of the signatories of the letter, who is also executive director of Humane Society International, told the BBC: "As a group of vets we think that in issuing the advice he has the chief vet is not taking full account of the independent scientific evidence available to him and in not doing so he is not only potentially condemning more badgers but also potentially putting cattle and therefore farmers at greater risk from the impact of bovine TB."

But Nigel Gibbons rejected the allegations and said he would not retract his advice to the secretary of state.

In a letter seen by the BBC, he wrote: "The disease control rationale in my advice is well founded and there is nothing in your letter to refute it.

"I am neither acting irresponsibly nor risking bringing the profession into disrepute and you are wrong to make this assertion.

"Finally I can assure you that the Government will await the conclusions of the independent expert panel before making any decisions on the wider roll out of culling as part of a comprehensive strategy for the control of bovine tuberculosis."

Ministers and the NFU say culling badgers will curb TB in cattle, but protesters say it has little effect.

A Defra spokesperson said: "The clear advice of the chief veterinary officer is that the more badgers removed in the first year of the cull, the greater and quicker reductions in the cull area will be.

"Bovine TB is a devastating disease for our dairy and cattle farmers and we must do everything we can to stop its spread."

Lou Reed, Velvet Underground frontman, dies at 71 - BBC News

Lizo Mzimba looks back at the life of Lou Reed

US singer and former Velvet Underground frontman Lou Reed has died at the age of 71.

Known for tracks including Perfect Day and Walk on the Wild Side, Reed was considered one of the most influential singers and songwriters in rock.

The Velvet Underground became renowned for their fusion of art and music and for collaborating with Andy Warhol.

According to the Associated Press news agency, Reed's literary agent said he died of a "liver-related ailment".

Andrew Wylie said the musician died at his home in Long Island, New York, on Sunday morning and had not been well "for a few months".

Backing singer Casey Synge describes working with Reed on Walk on the Wild Side

Reed's former Velvet Underground bandmate John Cale wrote on his website: "The world has lost a fine songwriter and poet… I've lost my 'school-yard buddy.'"

Other stars paying tribute included The Who, who tweeted: "RIP Lou Reed. Walk on the peaceful side." Iggy Pop said it was "devastating news".

An admitted hard drinker and drug user for many years, Reed had a liver transplant this May after suffering liver failure.

"I am a triumph of modern medicine," Reed posted on his website on 1 June.

The Velvet Underground never achieved commercial success during their 1960s existence, but their influence on music in later decades was widely recognised.

The punk, glam and alternative rock movements of the 1970s, '80s and '90s were all indebted to Reed, whose songs were covered by the likes of REM, David Bowie, Nirvana, Patti Smith and countless others.

Music producer Brian Eno once summed up their influence by saying: "The first Velvet Underground album only sold 10,000 copies, but everyone who bought it formed a band."

The group were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1996.

After quitting The Velvet Underground in 1970, Reed released his self-titled debut in 1972, but it wasn't until the Bowie-produced LP Transformer later that year - which featured both Perfect Day and Walk on the Wild Side - that he achieved chart success.

Perfect Day enjoyed a second bout of success in 1996 when it was featured in Danny Boyle's Trainspotting, and again a year later when it was re-recorded by a celebrity cast for a BBC charity single.

As a solo artist, he released 20 studio albums. His last, Hudson River Wind Meditations, was released in 2007.

He is survived by his second wife, the musician and performing artist, Laurie Anderson.

Others paying tribute included US rock band Weezer, who said The Velvet Underground were "a big influence" when they were starting out.

Chic guitarist Nile Rogers said: "I did the Jools Holland show with him last year and we yucked it up. I didn't know he was ill."

Meanwhile, singer Marianne Faithfull said: "He was a great friend, musician, songwriter and band leader. One of the most intelligent musicians I've ever known and a great guitarist.

"His songs will live for ever... Perfect Day, Sweet Jane... In my opinion he was a genius. I will miss him terribly."

And Def Jam founder Russell Simmons tweeted: "New York lost one of our greatest gifts today."

What are your memories of Lou Reed? Did you ever meet or work with him? Send us your thoughts and pictures?

Send your pictures and videos to yourpics@bbc.co.uk or text them to 61124 (UK) or +44 7624 800 100 (International). If you have a large file you can upload here.

Read the terms and conditions

Why is broadband more expensive in the US? - BBC News

Home broadband in the US costs far more than elsewhere. At high speeds, it costs nearly three times as much as in the UK and France, and more than five times as much as in South Korea. Why?

Men's haircuts, loaves of bread... it is surprising how much more expensive some things are in the US than the UK. Now home broadband can be added to that list.

The price of basic broadband, TV and phone packages - or bundles as they are known - is much higher in American cities than elsewhere, suggests the New America Foundation think tank, which compared hundreds of available packages worldwide.

Looking at some of the cheaper ones available in certain cities, at lower to mid download speeds, San Francisco ($99/£61), New York ($70) and Washington DC ($68) dwarf London ($38), Paris ($35) and Seoul ($15).

This research echoes the findings of another report earlier in the summer by the OECD, which compared countries in terms of their broadband-only prices. Across all 10 download speeds and capacities, it consistently ranked the US near the bottom.

For instance, at high speeds of 45 Mbps and over, the OECD report has the US ranked 30th out of 33 countries, with an average price of $90 a month. With phone and TV thrown in, plus some premium channels, these packages often cost $200.

The bedroom door problem

The 32-year-old editor of a design magazine pays $37 a month to Comcast for a cable broadband package. She doesn't have a TV or a landline phone.

"It's fine in the majority of the apartment but if I'm on my bed, I have to hold my laptop three feet away towards the open doorway of the bedroom because the signal is so weak.

"It's a pain when you're in a 2am coma and trying to watch The West Wing and you don't really want to move. But if you're in the living room in the vicinity of the router then the speed is fine. I don't think it's good value because I pay the same for unlimited data on my phone and I expect more from a service at home on my laptop."

"Americans pay so much because they don't have a choice," says Susan Crawford, a former special assistant to President Barack Obama on science, technology and innovation policy.

Although there are several national companies, local markets tend to be dominated by just one or two main providers.

"We deregulated high-speed internet access 10 years ago and since then we've seen enormous consolidation and monopolies, so left to their own devices, companies that supply internet access will charge high prices, because they face neither competition nor oversight."

Two-thirds get their broadband via their television cables, she says, because the DSL (digital subscriber line) service provided by phone companies over copper lines can't compete with cable speeds, while wireless and satellite services are subject to low usage caps.

San Francisco seems to be particularly expensive.

Mitch Evans pays $200 a month for internet, TV and unlimited voice phone calls. "I guess I've just become used to it after 23 years here in the Bay Area. I know the cost of living here is very high, but for me it's a small price to pay for such a beautiful and wonderful place to call home."

Buck Wallander, a recent arrival in the city, pays $120 a month for a television and broadband package provided by Xfinity/Comcast, plus $7 a month to "rent" the modem.

'No patience for downloads'

In recent years, the commuting experience in Seoul has suddenly become more enjoyable. The subways may be packed, but the corporate warriors are now armed with the latest smartphones, consumed in their daily ritual of listening to music and watching TV dramas on board.

That's because the metro system is equipped with free wi-fi. For a country that was flattened 60 years ago by a war that took over a million lives, it's remarkable how South Korea has turned itself in to an internet powerhouse.

South Korea has become the ultra-modern society where efficiency and speed are now considered some of the top virtues. Few now have the patience, or the need, to wait around for downloads - films and music have become nearly instant and HDTV on the internet a reality.

And one of the reasons why so many households can afford to have broadband is the low price. For about $20, most homes enjoy 100 Mbps to satisfy their entertainment needs.

He says he had little choice in selecting a provider because the only other cable television company was directv, which didn't offer any internet service. His internet speed is "entry-level" with a cap on usage. He says he's pretty satisfied with the service but resents leasing the modem.

"That's like a rental car company charging customers an extra $7 fee per month to include the steering wheel."

Elsewhere in the US, there is a patchwork of other options.

In Kansas City, Kansas, residents are enjoying a high-speed fibre network, supplied by Google, at a price of $70 a month for a gigabit (1,000 Mbps) internet-only service. And there's a slower 5 Mbps download speed for free for seven years to those who pay $300 up front. Google now has Austin, Texas, and Provo, Utah, in its sights, too. Verizon also has a super fast fibre network, Fios, available to 10% of US households.

About 150 cities across the US have internet access supplied by public utility companies. In Chattanooga, Tennessee, electricity company EPB became an internet service provider four years ago. After expanding its existing fibre network which it used to control the grid, it now offers a one gigabit service for $70 a month.

These new services have had a positive impact on prices, says Chris Mitchell, director of telecommunications at the Institute for Local Self-Reliance.

"When a community builds its own network it enters the market with a lower price than the incumbents had been offering. Often the incumbent then lowers their price - often even further than the municipal network is offering - so when a community starts offering a service the prices typically drop."

In Lafayette, Louisiana, $35 can get you 15Mbps from the municipal internet service. But only one in 10 US cities have public electricity utilities and 19 states have discouraged or banned communities from building these networks, says Mitchell.

'US ahead of Europe'

A decade ago the European broadband market may have looked healthy from the standpoint of consumer pricing, but after 10 years of underinvestment, European households (only half of which have access to networks capable of speeds of even 30 megabits) have far fewer broadband options and innovations than their American counterparts.

Lowell C McAdam, Verizon chairman

For Susan Crawford, author of Captive Audience, higher prices have created a digital divide which excludes poor Americans from quality internet access. And there are economic implications too.

"The 2008 banking crisis demonstrated what happens when we allow banks to act out of pure self interest. The communications crisis in America is less visible but also destructive of America's ability to function on the global stage."

Like electricity, she says, internet access should be available equally to all at reasonable prices so that every other sector of US industry and society can flourish.

Rick Karr, who made a PBS documentary in which he travelled to the UK to find out why prices were lower, says that the critical moment came when the British regulator Ofcom forced British Telecom to allow other companies to use its copper telephone wires going to and from homes.

But US regulators took a different approach. Rather than encouraging competition between operators using the same network, the US encouraged competition between different infrastructure owners - big companies that could afford to build their own networks.

Some believe that UK-style regulation is bad for competition and innovation, however, and suggest that the US is already one of the world leaders in broadband.

Several studies show the US with broadband speeds as good as anyone, says Brian Dietz of the NCTA, the trade association for the US cable companies. High performing states like Vermont, New Hampshire and Delaware have faster average speeds than Japan, he says. And 96.3% of US households have access to wired broadband.

It's also very difficult to fairly make international comparisons on price, he says.

"Building broadband networks in a country with the sheer size and diverse geography of the US is definitely a factor when comparing but despite these challenges, the US is a leader in global broadband by any objective measure."

The critics should take a broader view, says Scott Cleland, chairman of NetCompetition, a pro-competition e-forum supported by broadband interests.

In Europe, people are selling different capacities at different prices, but the US encourages different technologies and a diversity of choice - people can choose phone, cable, wireless or satellite, he says. And suppliers can get a return from their investment which can be ploughed back into improving the infrastructure - $1.2tn has been reinvested since the mid 1990s.

But in Europe the funds aren't there, so it's Europe that is lagging behind on 4G and fibre, Cleland argues. "We may be paying more in your eyes today but we are building for tomorrow and the long-term."

The US is the only country in the world that provides a fast streaming cable service to everyone, he says.

Moaning about it, he thinks, is like complaining you only have access to a Rolls-Royce when you also have Fords, Chevys and Cadillacs to choose from.

Follow @BBCNewsMagazine on Twitter and on Facebook

Are you in broadband heaven or hell? Tell us what it's like where you live

Sunday, 27 October 2013

Danny Alexander 'confident' HS2 will be within budget - BBC News

Danny Alexander on the HS2 project: "We have set the budget and we will stick to it"

Treasury minister Danny Alexander has said he is "very confident" the HS2 high-speed rail project will be delivered within its £42.6bn budget.

He told the BBC's Andrew Marr Show the government was using the "same techniques" to ensure efficiency as for the 2012 London Olympics.

Supporters say the plan to link London to Manchester and Leeds will reduce journey times and boost growth.

But Labour's deputy leader Harriet Harman said costs had to be monitored.

The aim is to get trains running as fast as 250mph (400km/h) between London and Birmingham from 2026, with branches to Manchester and Leeds via Sheffield planned for 2033.

The estimated cost of the project has risen from £34.2bn to £42.6bn - plus £7.5bn for rolling stock.

'Working hard'

Mr Alexander, Chief Secretary to the Treasury, insisted this would not change, saying: "The real cost is the budget that we set out in June this year: £42.6bn. It hasn't changed at all.

"That number includes within it a significant amount of contingency.

"I'm very confident that, as we work through the project and deliver it, we will not just deliver it within that budget but, like the Olympic Stadium project, under budget too.

"That is something I'm working very, very hard to make sure happens. We are applying the same techniques we used to deliver the Olympic Park to the HS2 project."

Mr Alexander added: "We have set that budget and we will stick to it."

For Labour, shadow chancellor Ed Balls is reported to have compared HS2 to the Millennium Dome, saying: "I think you should learn from your mistakes."

But Ms Harman played down the comments, saying Mr Balls had been asked about the Dome by a Mail on Sunday journalist and had not volunteered the comparison.

She told the Andrew Marr Show: "We absolutely support better north-south lines. We are in favour of rail infrastructure for commuters and also for long-distance travellers and freight but not at any cost.

"And what Ed Balls is saying is we have to keep a strong eye on the costs as well as on the benefits.

"It's no good the government simply complaining about people who are raising these issues. They should be addressing these issues, controlling costs and being properly analytical about the benefits that are available."

Shadow energy secretary Caroline Flint told BBC One's Sunday Politics: "HS2 has never had a blank cheque from the Labour Party... We have to look for value for money and we have to look at how it benefits the country."

Bob Crow, general secretary of transport union RMT, said the "political posturing" over HS2 was a "smokescreen" designed to delay investment in the railways.